The poem
I like for you to be still It is as though you are absent And you hear me from far away And my voice does not touch you It seems as though your eyes had flown away And it seems that a kiss had sealed your mouth As all things are filled with my soul You emerge from the things Filled with my soul You are like my soul A butterfly of dream And you are like the word: Melancholy
I like for you to be still And you seem far away It sounds as though you are lamenting A butterfly cooing like a dove And you hear me from far away And my voice does not reach you Let me come to be still in your silence And let me talk to you with your silence That is bright as a lamp Simple, as a ring You are like the night With its stillness and constellations Your silence is that of a star As remote and candid
I like for you to be still It is as though you are absent Distant and full of sorrow So you would've died One word then, One smile is enough And I'm happy; Happy that it's not true

This poem makes me think... It makes me want to Dig deep into a soul, attempt to find an answer, a resolution. . .maybe to my own thoughts... bravo!
Maybe is just a problem with my english knowledge but I thought that being still is not to move.
In the poem he says that he likes when she is in silence, not talking (callas).
As if she is dead. He likes her silence because of the pleasure that arises when she breaks it.
i cried when i read this poem...i cried my self for her who sent me this poem..i cried for her, whom i cannot be with..
Me gustas cuando callas porque estás como ausente,
y me oyes desde lejos, y mi voz no te toca.
Parece que los ojos se te hubieran volado
y parece que un beso te cerrara la boca...
Poetry always sounds better in its original language
I agree that poems are better in their original language. This poem also moves me to tears and although my spanish is not to the point where I can read it fluently, I am very glad that I can translate it somewhat to the point that I can appreciate it in spanish.
Me gustas cuando callas porque estas como ausente.
Distante y dolorosa como si hubieras muerto.
Una palabra entonces, una sonrisa bastan.
Y estoy alegre, alegre de que no sea cierto.
Of course this translation does no right to it's original form... like Danielek said, "Me gustas cuando callas porque estás como ausente" can never be "I like for you to be still, it is as though you are absent" it gives it a different meaning... it just doesn't work. Poema XV: Me gustas cuando callas... Me gustas cuando callas porque estás como ausente, y me oyes desde lejos, y mi voz no te toca. Parece que los…
Read the whole commentOf course this translation does no right to it's original form... like Danielek said, "Me gustas cuando callas porque estás como ausente" can never be "I like for you to be still, it is as though you are absent" it gives it a different meaning... it just doesn't work.
Poema XV: Me gustas cuando callas...
Me gustas cuando callas porque estás como ausente,
y me oyes desde lejos, y mi voz no te toca.
Parece que los ojos se te hubieran volado
y parece que un beso te cerrara la boca.
Como todas las cosas están llenas de mi alma
emerges de las cosas, llena del alma mía.
Mariposa de sueño, te pareces a mi alma,
y te pareces a la palabra melancolía.
Me gustas cuando callas y estás como distante.
Y estás como quejándote, mariposa en arrullo.
Y me oyes desde lejos, y mi voz no te alcanza:
déjame que me calle con el silencio tuyo.
Déjame que te hable también con tu silencio
claro como una lámpara, simple como un anillo.
Eres como la noche, callada y constelada.
Tu silencio es de estrella, tan lejano y sencillo.
Me gustas cuando callas y estás como ausente.
Distante y dolorosa como si hubieras muerto.
Una palabra entonces, una sonrisa bastan.
Y estoy alegre, alegre de que no sea cierto.
--Pablo Neruda. Veinte poemas de amor y una canción desesperada.
No cabe duda que el español sigue siendo el lenguaje más rico y bello del mundo... :)
This could be a triple-entendre. He doesn't exactly say "I like it when you LIE still" but that is an insinuation as well. But a married man (no, I'm not) would recognize this carefully-worded request. Google translated it in the direct terms he's probably thinking: >Poem XV: I like when you shut up... >...and seems that a kiss closed your mouth. Then our married man qualifies - uh, backtracks "I didn't mean that" -…
Read the whole commentThis could be a triple-entendre. He doesn't exactly say "I like it when you LIE still" but that is an insinuation as well.
But a married man (no, I'm not) would recognize this carefully-worded request. Google translated it in the direct terms he's probably thinking:
>Poem XV: I like when you shut up...
>...and seems that a kiss closed your mouth.
Then our married man qualifies - uh, backtracks "I didn't mean that" - as a properly-trained married man should do:
>...and painful as if you had died.
But gets the last word by cajoling "Enough, already!":
>One word then, One smile is enough
>And I'm happy;
And now we hear his wife, hurt, saying "You want me to play dead?"
(Or more ominously "You better not tell me to shut up, you $%^%$".
And he again clarifies/qualifies - uh, backtracks:
>Happy that it's not true
There is a band called "Brazilian Girls" that does an amazing rendition of this poem
Everyone that's posted seems to understand this poem really well. I have to analyze this poem for a spanish class, and I am having a hard time understanding it...my spanish is not the greatest. Any ideas of what this poem means to anyone would be greatly appreciated!
One must remember that the poem itself was written by a machista point of view. Woman at this time were mere trinckets, something to be seen and not heard. I say to mi esposo quite often "me gustas cuando callas," because I can enjoy his company in silence, not because he is better that way!
I like for you to be still.
É bem difícil prá mim traduzir esta frase.
There is something very intimate and comforting in knowing that you can be next to a person you love and you don't need to talk. Not only there is some sort of complicity in the situation, there is implicit understanding. You can only do such a thing with somebody you feel very comfortable with, otherwise the silent would make you uneasy and you would feel that saying something it is necessary.
i'm fifteen and though i have yet to experience a love where i am comfortable enough to embrace my lovers silence this poem moves me to a place that makes me want nothing more than for my heart to sit in contentment with him. neruda has done it once again.
the silence that comes with a close friendship can be taken the same way i can assume.
Chinese translation of this poem~ beautiful
I like for you to be still: it is as though you are absent and you hear me from far away,and my voice does not touch you. It seems as through your eyes had flown away and it seems that a kiss had sealed your mouth 我喜欢你是静静的:仿佛你消失了一样 你从远处聆听我,我的声音却无法触及你 好像你的目光已经游离而去 如同一个吻,封缄了你的嘴 as all things are filled with my soul your emerge from the things, fill with my soul you are like my soul, a butterfly of dreams and you are…
Read the whole commentI like for you to be still: it is as though you are absent
and you hear me from far away,and my voice does not touch you.
It seems as through your eyes had flown away
and it seems that a kiss had sealed your mouth
我喜欢你是静静的:仿佛你消失了一样
你从远处聆听我,我的声音却无法触及你
好像你的目光已经游离而去
如同一个吻,封缄了你的嘴
as all things are filled with my soul
your emerge from the things, fill with my soul
you are like my soul, a butterfly of dreams
and you are like the word melancholy
如同我积满一切的灵魂
而你从一切中出现,充盈了我的灵魂
你像我的灵魂,像一只梦想的蝴蝶
你如同“忧郁”这个词
I like for you to be still, and you seem far away
It sounds as though you are lamenting, a butterfly cooing like a dove
And you hear me from far away, and my voice does not reach you
Let me come to be still in your silence
我喜欢你是静静的:好像你已远去
你听起来像在悲叹,一只如鸽般细语的蝴蝶
你从远处聆听我,我的声音却无法触及你
让我在你的静谧中安静无声
And let me talk to you with your silence
That is bright like a lamp, simple as a ring
You are like the night, with its stillness and constellations
Your silence is that of a star, as remont and candid
并且让我籍着你的沉默与你说话
你的沉默亮若明灯,简单如环
你如黑夜,拥有寂静与群星
你像我的灵魂,像一只梦想的蝴蝶
I like for you to be still: it is as though you are absent
distant and dull of sorrow, as though you had died
One word then, one smile, is enough
And I’a happy, happy that’s not true
我喜欢你是静静的:仿佛你消失了一样
远隔千里,满怀哀恸,仿佛你已不在人世
彼时,一个字,一个微笑,就已足够
而我会感到幸福,因那不是真的而感到幸福
about 4 years ago I first met this poem .it was posted on a digest magazine in chinese .I was immediately touched by its fantasy metaphor .
I've never read its original 'cos I got no idea about spanish .but for it ,I think I got some interest now .